North Wales Crusaders were knocked out of the Challenge Cup at the fourth round stage by amateur club Thatto Heath (writes Ryan Gould).

Despite staging a late comeback and being close to taking the tie to golden point extra time, North Wales were second best for large spells and were out-muscled, out-thought and out-enthused by Thatto Heath.

The home side defended excellently, particularly in the second-half, to keep the visitors out and hung on at the end to secure a memorable and deserved victory.

The opening exchanges felt a little cagey and you could tell North Wales were going to be in for a tough afternoon from the outset.

Thatto took the lead when Lewis Foster spotted a gap in the defensive line to scoot over from acting half.

Warren Thompson went close to replying for the visitors, only to be stopped short of the line as he darted on the last play.

The amateurs then had a big opportunity to extend their lead after a nice shift to the left wing, but Matty Norton’s final pass to Niall Allen was forward and flew into touch.

Thatto didn’t make the same mistake when they next found themselves in good field position as Connor Dwyer forced his way over down the left, despite Gavin Conroy’s efforts to hold him up in-goal.

However, North Wales did pull one back shortly before half-time through Rob Massam, who picked up the ball at acting half and barged his way over in the left corner.

The hosts were given a penalty early in the second half and opted to kick for goal, but Bobbie Goulding dragged it wide of the sticks.

Thatto did build on their lead soon after, though, as a North Wales attack was charged down and Norton collected the loose ball to race clear underneath the posts.

Although the away side had Simon Atherton’s effort down the right ruled out for a knock-on, Chris Worrall manage to cross in the same corner as they began to stage a comeback.

North Wales thought they’d taken the tie to golden point extra time when Rob Massam collected Earl Hurst’s pass to grab his second late on, but Ben Stead missed the conversion to draw North Wales level.

The League 1 club charged forward looking for another try in the dying seconds, but Thatto held on.

THATTO HEATH
1 Ben Heyes
2 Adam Saunders
3 Corey Lee
4 Matty Norton
5 Niall Allen
6 Josh Crehan
7 Bobbie Goulding
10 Mark Stark
9 Lewis Foster
8 Andy Lea (C)
11 Adam Predergast
13 Connor Dwyer
12 Jamie Tracey
Subs:
17 Luke Bradshaw
15 Adam Hesketh
16 Max Dudley
21 Brad Ashurst

Tries: Foster (12), Dwyer (28), Norton (51)
Goals: Goulding (2/4)

NORTH WALES
1 Danny Price
2 Gavin Conroy
3 Simon Atherton
4 Earl Hurst
5 Rob Massam
6 Steve Roper
7 Ryan Smith
8 Callum Hazzard
9 Karl Ashall
10 Warren Thompson
11 Jack Houghton
12 Chris Worrall
13 Kenny Baker (C)
Subs (all used)
14 Ben Stead
15 Brad Brennan
16 Alex Eckley
17 Jonny Walker

Tries: Massam (32, 79), Worrall (68)
Goals: Baker (0/1), Stead (1/2)

Referee: John McMullen
HT: 10-4
Attendance: 737